Like most highlight videos—this is the point of a highlight video—Gary looks great on film. He's fast, can make plays, and showcases a disruptive speed when engaged. However, his cumulative production numbers don't meet the high-level expectation set by these Vine-length snippets of explosion. Was Gary's lingering shoulder issue more of a big deal than publicly known? Or was something else happening?
Unlike their counterparts in the NBA, NHL and MLB, high school football players have to attend college for three seasons before declaring for the NFL Draft. The biggest critiques of Gary have been about his effort and his motor, but that didn't stop Big 10 coaches from making Gary a First Team All-Big-10 selection in 2017 and 2018, despite the fact that he didn't rank in the top five in any major pass rush category. But production is only one piece of the equation: I remember similar scouting concerns surrounding Jadaveon Clowney when he came out of South Carolina, and he turned out to be a productive NFL player, a difference-maker when healthy.
Gary, also, has an entrepreneurial bent: His name is trademarked, and last year, he announced that he would start his own sports agency as he entered the NFL Draft—a rookie contract is pretty straightforward, and Gary is using the opportunity to build his own business, with assists from his mother, Jennifer Coney, and veteran NFL Agent Ian Clarke.
Overall, Gary's high selection is the latest chapter in the time-tested NFL Draft narrative: do you draft for upside and potential, or do you draft productive college players and hope it translates? That's why Gary occupies such a prominent space in the imagination today.